When the depth of the actual neutral axis in a beam is greater than the depth of the critical neutral axis, then the beam is called:

When the depth of the actual neutral axis in a beam is greater than the depth of the critical neutral axis, then the beam is called: Correct Answer over-reinforced section

Explanation:

​Over-reinforced section:

  • The depth of the actual neutral axis (Xu) is greater than the depth of the critical neutral axis (Xulim).
  • The stress in concrete reaches its permissible value before steel.
  • Failure is also sudden in over-reinforced sections because concrete is brittle in nature and in over-reinforced sections concrete fails prior to steel.
  • In the over-reinforced section, the steels are not yielded fully, so the over-reinforced section is considered uneconomical.


Comparison Between under-reinforced section, balanced section, and over-reinforced section:

Under reinforced

Balanced section

Over reinforced

Xu < Xu(lim)

Xu = Xu(lim)

Xu > Xu(lim)

Ast < Ast(lim)

Ast = Ast(lim)

Ast > Ast(lim)

MOR < MORlim

MOR = MORlim

MOR > MORlim

Z > Zlim

Z = Zlim

Z < Zlim

Steel yields first then concrete reaches a maximum strain of 0.0035

Both steel yields and concrete reaches a maximum strain of 0.0035 simultaneously

Concrete reaches a maximum strain of 0.0035 before steel yields

The final failure is due to cracking of concrete (when strain is 0.0035)

Ductile failure (Gradual / Warning is issued)

 

Brittle failure (Sudden / No warning is issued)

Secondary compression failure

 

Primary compression failure

Related Questions

If the depth of actual neutral axis in a beam is more than the depth of critical neutral axis, then the beam is called
A singly reinforced beam has breadth b, effective depth d, depth of neutral axis n and critical neutral axis n1. If fc and ft are permissible compressive and tensile stresses, the moment to resistance of the beam, is
If the modular ratio is ‘m’, steel ratio is ‘r’ and overall depth of a beam is ‘d’, the depth of the critical neutral axis of the beam, is