When the depth of the actual neutral axis in a beam is greater than the depth of the critical neutral axis, then the beam is called:
When the depth of the actual neutral axis in a beam is greater than the depth of the critical neutral axis, then the beam is called: Correct Answer over-reinforced section
Explanation:
Over-reinforced section:
- The depth of the actual neutral axis (Xu) is greater than the depth of the critical neutral axis (Xulim).
- The stress in concrete reaches its permissible value before steel.
- Failure is also sudden in over-reinforced sections because concrete is brittle in nature and in over-reinforced sections concrete fails prior to steel.
- In the over-reinforced section, the steels are not yielded fully, so the over-reinforced section is considered uneconomical.
Comparison Between under-reinforced section, balanced section, and over-reinforced section:
|
Under reinforced |
Balanced section |
Over reinforced |
|
Xu < Xu(lim) |
Xu = Xu(lim) |
Xu > Xu(lim) |
|
Ast < Ast(lim) |
Ast = Ast(lim) |
Ast > Ast(lim) |
|
MOR < MORlim |
MOR = MORlim |
MOR > MORlim |
|
Z > Zlim |
Z = Zlim |
Z < Zlim |
|
Steel yields first then concrete reaches a maximum strain of 0.0035 |
Both steel yields and concrete reaches a maximum strain of 0.0035 simultaneously |
Concrete reaches a maximum strain of 0.0035 before steel yields |
|
The final failure is due to cracking of concrete (when strain is 0.0035) |
||
|
Ductile failure (Gradual / Warning is issued) |
|
Brittle failure (Sudden / No warning is issued) |
|
Secondary compression failure |
|
Primary compression failure |