Given below are two premises with four conclusions drawn from them. Which of the following conclusions could be validity drawn from the premises? Premises: (i) All fans are tubes (ii) Bulbs are not tubes Conclusions: (A) Fans are not bulbs (B) All tubes are fans (C) Fans are bulbs (D) No tube is bulb Select the correct answer from the options given below:

Given below are two premises with four conclusions drawn from them. Which of the following conclusions could be validity drawn from the premises? Premises: (i) All fans are tubes (ii) Bulbs are not tubes Conclusions: (A) Fans are not bulbs (B) All tubes are fans (C) Fans are bulbs (D) No tube is bulb Select the correct answer from the options given below: Correct Answer (A) and (D)

Minimum possible figure

[ src="//storage.googleapis.com/tb-img/production/20/05/UGC%20NET%20Paper%201%2021%20June%202019%20Shift%201_4Qs_LR.docx%203.PNG" style="width: 253px; height: 118px;">

(A) Fans are not bulbs → True (Fans are tubes and tubes are not bulb this implies fans are  not blub)

(B) All tubes are fans → False (This can be possible but not denfinite)

(C) Fans are bulbs → False (It is definitely false as Fans are tubes and tubes are not bulb this implies fans are  not blub)

(D) No tube is bulb → True (It is clearly given primise)

Hence, only (A) and (D) are true. 

Related Questions