Using grease on your hair and scalp that's not designed to be used that way can be harmful to both your hair and skin, so I would suggest playing it safe and sticking to products that are designed to be used as hair grease.
Use grease. It’s longer lasting. When it heats up from riding, it becomes more liquid like and less like jelly. After riding, it cools back down and gets like jelly...
If your hair is severely damaged, it will not be possible to get a color that requires pre-lightening, such as pink, without risking severe damage and breakage.