A mixture of ice and water is contained in a piston cylinder arrangement as shown in figure. If heat  is added in the system and the piston is allowed to move as the ice melts. The Heat Q and the work W for the system ( water + ice ) are:

A mixture of ice and water is contained in a piston cylinder arrangement as shown in figure. If heat  is added in the system and the piston is allowed to move as the ice melts. The Heat Q and the work W for the system ( water + ice ) are: Correct Answer Q > 0, W < 0

Explanation:

  • Heat is added to the system which is taken as positive, i.e. Q > 0, if Heat added to the system.
  • Water exhibits an anomalous behavior, it contracts on heating between 0°C and 4°C.
  • The volume of a given amount of water decreases as it is cooled from room temperature until its temperature reaches 4°C. Below 4 °C, the volume increases, and therefore the density decreases.
  • This means that water has a maximum density at 4°C
  • As explained above, when we cool water below 4°C the water molecules present in ice form have a lot of empty space within the ice crystal.
  • As the ice melt, the inter-molecular distance decreases, when the water comes to 4 °C then the density of the water will increase first and then decrease as shown below.

​Mistake Points

  • On increasing temperature volume is not always increases, here behavior of water is anonymously different from other material.
  • Here generally students marked as W > 0 when heat is added to the system which is incorrect.

Related Questions

Jar A comprises a mixture of milk and water in the ratio of 3 : 2 respectively. Another mixture of milk and water is added to jar A and the ratio of milk and water in the resultant mixture changes. What was the initial quantity of mixture present in Jar A? I. The ratio of milk and water in the mixture that was added to Jar A was 2 : 1 respectively. II. The ratio of the new quantities of milk and water in Jar A was 8 : 5 respectively. The quantity of water in the mixture added to jar A was 6 litre.