Among the following propositions (a, b, c and d) two are related in such a way that both of them together cannot be false although they may both be true. Select the code that states those two propositions. a) All students are intelligent. b) Some students are intelligent. c) No students are intelligent. d) Some students are not intelligent.
Among the following propositions (a, b, c and d) two are related in such a way that both of them together cannot be false although they may both be true. Select the code that states those two propositions. a) All students are intelligent. b) Some students are intelligent. c) No students are intelligent. d) Some students are not intelligent. Correct Answer b and d
A proposition is the most basic element of logic. It is a declarative sentence that is either true or false.
There are four ways in which propositions may be opposed as Contradictories, Contraries, Sub-contraries, Subalterns and Superalterns.
Contradictories- The standard form of a categorical proposition that has the same subject and predicate term but differs from each other in both quantity and quality. Two propositions if one is denial of the other if they can’t be true or can’t be both false.
For example –
All students are intelligent.
Some students are not intelligent.
Contraries- Two propositions are said to be contraries if they can’t both be true, and the truth of one entails the truth of other i.e. both can’t be true and both can’t be false. If either of these propositions is true, then the other must be false.
For example –
All students are intelligent.
No students are intelligent.
Subcontraries- If the particular propositions having the same subject and predicate terms but differing in quality, one affirming the other denying. Two propositions are said to be subcontraries if both of them together cannot be false although they may both be true.
For example –
Some students are intelligent.
Some students are not intelligent.
Subalternation- It is the opposition between a Universal proposition and its corresponding proposition. In the corresponding particular proposition, the universal proposition is called the superaltern and the particular proposition is called subaltern. These propositions have the same subject and predicate terms and agree on quality. Both are affirming or both denying but differ in quantity.
For example –
No students are intelligent.
Some students are not intelligent.
Hence, the propositions that -‘Some students are intelligent’ and ‘Some students are not intelligent’ related in such a way that both of them together cannot be false although they may both be true.