Consider the following statements with reference to Indian Councils Act, 1861 1. Legislative councils had no control over budget. 2. Legislative councils could discuss executive action. 3. Secretary of state could disallow a legislation. Which of the above statements is/are incorrect? Select the correct answer using the code given below:

Consider the following statements with reference to Indian Councils Act, 1861 1. Legislative councils had no control over budget. 2. Legislative councils could discuss executive action. 3. Secretary of state could disallow a legislation. Which of the above statements is/are incorrect? Select the correct answer using the code given below: Correct Answer 2 only

The correct answer is option 3, i.e 2 only.

Key Points

  • Provisions under Indian Councils Act, 1861
    • The 1861 Act marked an advance in that the principle of representatives of non-officials in legislative bodies became accepted; laws were to be made after due deliberation, and as pieces of legislation they could be changed only by the same deliberative process.
    • Law-making was thus no longer seen as the exclusive business of the executive.
    • The portfolio system introduced by Lord Canning laid the foundations of cabinet government in India, each branch of the administration having its official head and spokesman in the government, who was responsible for its administration.
    • The Act by vesting legislative powers in the Governments of Bombay and Madras and by making provision for the institution of similar legislative councils in other provinces laid the foundations of legislative devolution.
    • The councils could not discuss important matters and no financial matters at all without previous approval of government.
    • They had no control over budget.

Mistake Points

  • They could not discuss executive action. Hence, Statement 2 is NOT correct.
    • Final passing of the bill needed viceroy’s approval.
    • Even if approved by the viceroy, the secretary of state could disallow a legislation.
    • Indians associated as non-officials were members of elite sections only.

Related Questions

In the question below, are given a statement followed by three courses of actions numbered I, II and III. On the basis of the information given, you have to assume everything in the statement to be true, and then decide which of the suggested course of action logically follow (s) for pursuing. Statement: Commerce and industry minister Suresh Prabhu will next week review sector-specific strategies to increase India’s exports 20% this year amid an uncertain global trade environment and credit availability. The ministry has identified nine sectors, including gems & jewellery, leather, textiles, agriculture and pharmaceuticals, to drive India’s exports to $400 billion in the next five years. These sectors accounted for $242 billion or 80% of the country’s total exports of $302 billion in 2017-18. Courses of action: I. The minister will review the action plans on October 1. This is in continuation of the series of meetings that he has had with export promotion councils and secretaries of line ministries concerned. II. Besides export promotion councils, the minister will separately meet officials of other departments concerned.  III. Exporters have raised concerns over the slack flow of credit to exporters, high goods and services tax on gold and strict pollution norms for chemicals, besides currency fluctuations, citing these factors as hindrances to export growth. Prabhu recently wrote to finance minister Arun Jaitley, requesting his intervention to improve bank credit flow to the export sector.